#Strategy#AI

Why Your Next Website Should Be Built by AI (With a Human at the Helm)

January 20, 2025·8 min read

The State of Play

Two years ago, suggesting that AI could build production-quality websites was a fringe position. Today, it is an operational reality. The tools have matured. The workflows have been refined. And the results speak for themselves.

But there is a critical distinction that most of the conversation misses: AI-generated websites and AI-augmented websites are fundamentally different things. One is a commodity. The other is a competitive advantage.

The AI Advantage: Speed, Cost, Quality

The traditional web development trilemma says you can have two of three: fast, cheap, or good. AI breaks this constraint — not by eliminating trade-offs entirely, but by shifting the curve.

Speed

AI-augmented development delivers production code at roughly 3x the pace of traditional workflows. This is not a theoretical estimate. It is a measured output from real projects across multiple agencies and enterprise teams.

The speed comes from eliminating mechanical work: boilerplate, responsive logic, accessibility markup, test scaffolding. The strategic and creative work — the parts that actually matter — still take the same amount of time. But they represent a smaller percentage of the total project.

Cost

When a four-month project becomes a six-week project, the math changes. Fewer billable hours. Less overhead. Lower risk of scope creep. The cost reduction typically lands between 40-60%, depending on project complexity.

This does not mean the work is worth less. It means the delivery model is more efficient. The value to the client — a high-quality, performant website — remains the same or improves.

Quality

This is the counterintuitive part. AI-augmented projects tend to have fewer bugs, higher test coverage, and better performance scores than their traditionally built counterparts.

Why? Because the mechanical errors that plague hand-written code — inconsistent spacing, missed accessibility attributes, untested edge cases — are exactly the kind of patterns that AI handles well. The human developer is freed to focus on architecture, performance optimization, and user experience refinement.

But Will It Look Generic?

This is the most common objection, and it deserves a direct answer: it depends entirely on who is operating the AI.

AI trained on millions of websites will, by default, produce output that looks like the average of those millions of websites. If you hand the tool to someone without design training, you will get a generic result. This is no different from handing Photoshop to someone without design training — the tool does not create taste.

The difference is in the operator. A team with strong design sensibility, clear brand understanding, and the technical skill to customize AI output will produce something distinctive. The AI accelerates execution. The humans define direction.

At Roar Creative, our design direction comes from a collaboration with a Milan-based studio. Our strategic thinking comes from years of enterprise and startup experience. AI is the engine. We are the drivers.

The Human at the Helm

Here is what AI cannot do, and what we do not expect it to do:

—Understand your business context. Why does your company exist? What does your audience need to feel? What differentiates you from competitor X? These are strategic questions that require human judgment.

—Make taste-level decisions. Which typeface conveys the right tone? How much whitespace is enough? When should an animation be subtle and when should it be bold? Taste is accumulated expertise, not pattern matching.

—Navigate ambiguity. Real projects are full of unclear requirements, competing stakeholders, and evolving goals. Managing this complexity is a fundamentally human skill.

—Build relationships. Your website is part of a larger business strategy. The team building it needs to understand your goals, communicate trade-offs, and adapt to changing priorities. This requires trust, which requires humans.

The 70/30 Split

Our internal data suggests that roughly 70% of web development work is mechanical — the kind of implementation that AI can accelerate significantly. The remaining 30% is strategic and creative — the kind of work that defines whether the final product is forgettable or remarkable.

The mechanical 70% includes: component scaffolding, responsive layout implementation, accessibility markup, test writing, performance optimization, code formatting, and documentation.

The strategic 30% includes: information architecture, brand strategy, visual design direction, user experience design, content strategy, and creative direction.

AI makes the 70% faster. Humans make the 30% matter.

The ROI Calculation

For a typical mid-market website project, the numbers look like this:

—Traditional agency: 12-16 weeks, high five-figure to low six-figure budget

—AI-augmented agency: 4-6 weeks, 40-60% lower budget

—DIY with AI tools: 1-2 weeks, minimal cost — but the output reflects the operator skill

The middle option — AI-augmented with experienced professionals — represents the best value for most businesses. You get the speed and cost advantages of AI with the quality and strategic depth of experienced professionals.

How to Evaluate an AI-Powered Agency

If you are considering working with an agency that uses AI, here is what to look for:

—Do they have a portfolio of shipped work? AI-augmented development is not a slide deck. Ask to see live sites they have built.

—Is there a design team, or just developers? AI cannot replace design thinking. If the agency does not have dedicated designers, the output will be generic.

—Can they explain their process? A credible AI-augmented workflow is specific: which tools, at which stages, with what human oversight. Vague claims of "using AI" are a red flag.

—Do they have relevant industry experience? AI accelerates execution, but it does not create domain expertise. An agency building a fintech site should understand fintech.

—What is their approach to quality assurance? AI-generated code needs rigorous human review. Ask about their testing, review, and deployment processes.

The Bottom Line

AI-powered web development is not a gimmick and it is not a threat. It is a tool — a remarkably powerful one — that produces its best results in the hands of experienced professionals.

Your next website should absolutely be built with AI. It should also be built by humans who understand strategy, design, and engineering at a level that no model can replicate.

That is the combination that produces extraordinary work.

Next →The Italian Design Principle That Changed How We Build Websites

Ready for liftoff?

Start your mission→